What do Milk, Diesel, and Electric Vehicles all have in Common?

What do Milk, Diesel, and Electric Vehicles all have in Common?

David Hunt 03/04/2018 5

Here are the latest thoughts from our eMobility and Smart Cities advisor, Lukas Neckermann.

In 2017, the US state of Georgia revoked a $5,000 electric vehicle (EV) incentive program, and instead imposed the country’s highest extra fee for registering an EV. Georgia’s (Republican) lawmaker suggested their approach is “market driven [because] a free-market approach answers a lot of questions.”

Stefan Niemand, Head of Electrification at Audi, recently also went on record saying, “I personally don’t believe in subsidies at all. If a market needs that, it’s not healthy.” His comments mirror those of VW CEO Mathias Müller two months ago. Except that Niemand and Müller were not talking about an end to EV subsidies, but about diesel subsidies.

Economically, consumer incentives are designed to either nudge behaviour toward a desirable outcome, or to support a fledgling industry. Incentives for the purchase of EVs accomplish both – they support innovation in a growing industry (as China is showing us all too well), and promote adoption of “cleaner” vehicles (as Norway has done with resounding success). Given various air quality and smog crises around the world, it is right to – for a certain period – give incentives to vehicles that produce less harmful emissions (in virtually all cases, cradle-to-grave), and drive an industry with a CAGR of 20-40%, depending on the study.

In many countries and states, however, industry protectionism counterbalances the efforts of consumer EV incentives. Automotive plants producing internal-combustion engine vehicles are a top-5 industry in Georgia, and the state is among the top-10 petroleum consuming states in the US. No surprise then that, for all of their “free-market” talk, the Georgia lawmakers conveniently ignore some $14.5 billion per year in federal consumption subsidies for big-oil.

Two years ago, I penned an article, “Why bet on a dying horse”, after speaking at a conference of internal-combustion-engine developers in Germany. I noted their rejection of the EV revolution; what I perhaps underestimated, was their political clout. Both the UK and Germany have a lot to lose in the transition to electric vehicles. In Germany, the automobile industry represents some 15-20% of GDP (by various measures); the UK produces over 2.7 million petrol and diesel engines. It’s no surprise then that the respective auto trade associations keep declaring their love for internal-combustion engines. The SMMT goes further, farcically claiming that diesel vehicles can improve air quality.

Unlike schemes in many of its (non vehicle producing) European neighbours, consumer incentives for electric vehicles in Germany have been a flop (it’s worth noting they were neatly targeted to exclude Tesla vehicles, and dealers had no incentive to sell EVs). In turn, this past week, the state governments hosting the headquarters of BMW and VW respectively suggested a new scrappage scheme for consumers - €2,000 for buyers of “clean” (Euro 6d) Diesel vehicles. It’s hard to imagine a more disjointed approach, as the national government is simultaneously at least loosely discussing diesel-bans, just as many cities in neighbouring countries have planned.

Usually, any incentives should end when any critical mass is achieved, and when an industry is self-sufficient in its investments. For EVs, this should likely coincide with the time when prices (or better yet, total-cost-of-ownership) is more attractive than that of ICEs, which is anytime between now and 2025, depending on your industry, your geography, or which institute is doing the calculation. 

In practice, however, consumer and industry subsidies get perpetuated as a pinball of crony capitalism. Consumer and industry subsidies for the oil industry are just as absurd today as are the dairy subsidies that led the US to dump 43 million gallons of milk in 2016, or those that perpetuate sugar subsidies, nominally in the interest of national security.

I fully understand the need to manage a transition to zero emissions automobility, but in the words of The Economist, the internal-combustion engine “had a good run”. It’s time to take it off life-support. If they are serious about clean air and supporting growth industries, national governments should indeed let the market decide – and end those subsidies for oil and diesel that counteract their support for EVs.

Hyperion Executive Search are specialists in the recruitment of top talent in the EV Charging, eMobility and MaaS sectors.

Share this article

Leave your comments

Post comment as a guest

terms and condition.
  • Adam Dixon

    I think that more government subsidies would make electric vehicles more accessible.

  • Monica Shambler

    Most drivers could actually make the switch, they would only need to charge their car once a week.

  • Yorkshire Lad

    I'd love to see a big electric car industry in the U.K.

  • Brian Norton

    Interesting !!!

  • Danny Tully

    Good read

Share this article

David Hunt

Energy Expert

David Hunt is a prominent figure and thought leader in the clean energy sector. Hailed as a leading green entrepreneur by the Financial Times, David also presents at industry events such as EcoSummit, Energy Storage Europe and Fully Charged Live. David is a frequent contributor to trade publications such as Energy Storage News, Solar Power Portal, PV Tech, Clean Energy News and Smart Cities World. His industry insights have been quoted in UK broadsheet newspapers such as The Guardian, The Independent, The Telegraph and the Sunday Times. Being well versed in business and economics, he has also lent his voice to the likes of BBC Radio Four and ITV’s 6 O’clock news. A cleantech expert and industry insider, David specialises in the clean energy and eMobility sectors. His drive to accelerate these growing markets led him to set up Hyperion Executive Search Ltd, a talent acquisition company specialising in the clean energy space that incisively places talent where it’s needed. Hyperion has been helping businesses grow and succeed since 2014 and recently expanded its operations in Europe with a new office in Munich. David’s headhunting team now operates across EMEA and the US. Before this, David co-founded an award-winning multi-technology renewable energy installation business, sat as a policy board member with the UK Renewable Energy Association, and was a member of PRASEG (Parliamentary Renewable and Sustainable Energy Group). The ‘This week in cleantech’ podcast is a platform for David and invited experts to share and review the biggest, and most interesting news stories in the cleantech sector each week, providing expert opinion, analysis and insight. It is anticipated that the podcast will be a catalyst for the further growth and development of the cleantech revolution.

Cookies user prefences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Read more
Tools used to analyze the data to measure the effectiveness of a website and to understand how it works.
Google Analytics