Do We Have Too Many Managers and Administrators in Healthcare?

Do We Have Too Many Managers and Administrators in Healthcare?

Do We Have Too Many Managers and Administrators in Healthcare?

As the global healthcare industry faces mounting challenges, there is a growing need for innovative solutions.

While automation and digitization were initially seen as remedies, they have inadvertently created more work for healthcare professionals, leading to "inbox burnout" and an increased reliance on managers and administrators.

As the problems in healthcare on a global level stack, with hospitals closing down due to a shortage of skilled personnel, we look for solutions from out of a paradigm that has been de way to go for many decades: work harder, work more efficiently, and automation.

Though I do think more efficient workflows are possible once we clear up those silos that we are working from, both in process and in data, I also think this is not going to solve the challenges we’re facing.

Next, to transition from a ‘sick-care’ system towards a health system and incorporate more of the touchpoints from our daily life like retail (hence my Healthcare meets retail-mission), there is also the elephant in the room: managers and administrators.

Let me be frank: we need these roles, and many are fine people! But let’s look at automation and digitization of healthcare. Supposedly it would solve many of the problems we face(d), while the reality is it created more workload for professionals, by now distracting professionals up to 40% from looking at their patients, and invokes a new professionals-disease: “inbox burnout.”

And what do we see happening? We see an accelerated need for more managers and administrators to help with the interpretation of guidelines for care processes, collecting more data (it’s only one minute extra to fill out that field), and next, chasing professionals to make sense of the data that is being generated.

So, in short, we might not be able to get around the challenges by looking to technology and efficiency only. We need to put the patient and professional first and empower them with technology that actually saves them time. A statement like that can easily invoke new research to measure the ‘ist’ and ‘soll’, but just ask them! Just ask professionals if a new process, technology, or procedure would actually save them time and more ‘quality time with the patient.

Growth_in_Healthcare_Workers.png

Source: Investing Doc

If not, we’re just perpetuating the vicious cycle we’re in with a different label. Since the seventies, the growth of administrators outpaced that of physicians by over 2500%; even though this is somewhat skewed as some physicians took on double roles, percentile growth is relative (from 1 to 2 is 100% growth), and automation certainly also needed more administration; the numbers are staggering.

I think that it is possible that we have too many managers and administrators in healthcare. I think that this is something that needs to be looked at in order to see if it is truly the case.

So my hunch would be, in addition to working more efficiently, to create more relevant automation and change the paradigm from sick care to health, to also discuss a hold in creating new management roles and not replacing existing ones in case of a vacancy and explore the actual impact of such a new approach. Obviously, now with meticulous research done by professionals, but maybe simply by just going on: business as usual.

 

Share this article

Share this article

Lucien Engelen

Chief Health(care) Optimist

It is at the intersection of technology and patient empowerment, which is where Lucien Engelen (1962), director of the Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre REshape Center and advisor to the Board of Directors (since 2007) feels most at home. The two worlds combined into the Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre and Singularity University in Silicon Valley & the Netherlands and in the Nordics, his modus operandi is always challenging, sometimes provocative but always techno-realistic. Writing on a new book that will be titled "Augmented Health(care)™ : The end of the beginning" (May 2018, Barcelone Spain) as he thinks we're at the end of an era of creating awareness, pilots, proof of concepts etc in the digital transformation of health(care). More on that on, his Linkedin Page has over 750.000 followers. He is Faculty Global Health(care) & Medecine since 2011 at Singularity University's Exponential Medicine in the US and in the Netherlands.

   
Save
Cookies user prefences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Read more
Analytics
Tools used to analyze the data to measure the effectiveness of a website and to understand how it works.
Google Analytics
Accept
Decline