The Brexit Dilemma Set to Continue

The Brexit Dilemma Set to Continue

Alan Hill 23/07/2018 8

A question keeps occurring to me. Why is Brexit being decided along Party Political lines? Brexit is not an ideological issue. It makes no difference whether a voter leans left or right, there are Brexiteers and Remainers on both sides of the divide.

While the Conservative Party is cheered on, by Labour, in splitting itself in two over an issue which, admittedly they started, it is too important to this country for it to be simply viewed as a tool to see the return of a Socialist Government.

Watch the final scenes of the film “The Darkest Hour”. It is inconceivable that the opposition benches would have been criticising Churchill as he rallied the country with his “Fight them on the beaches” speech but as the country faces an economic if not a military catastrophe, Corbyn and his acolytes sit motionless eyeing the chance to form a Government. Admittedly Theresa May is neither the Statesman or Orator Churchill was, but it is time the Party-Political shackles were loosened.

It is said that there are three choices for Brexit; soft, hard or no deal. However, only no deal is possible under the present Parliamentary arrangement. As Mrs May leans towards a soft Brexit, she loses support from Brexiteers and as she sides with Brexiteers she loses Remainers. All this without even a reference to Brussels!

So how can a decision be made? General election? Another referendum? Neither is likely. I believe that no deal is now the most likely outcome simply as time is going to run out. A general election solves nothing, and as we saw in the 2016 referendum, the devil of that vote is in the question. It could not work on a binary basis. So, could it be a multiple choice? The choices would be remain, hard/no deal and soft.

The Economist Newspaper ran a series of surveys this week in which it used three polling methods for a multiple-choice ballot; First past the post, still too close to call, but remain won. Alternative vote where voters are asked for first and second choices and the outcome with the lowest votes sees its ballots allocated to its second choices. Under that scenario, hard wins. Finally, under a “Condorcet” style where the three scenarios are voted for against each other i.e. hard or remain? soft or hard? And hard or remain, soft wins. Of course, were there to be a referendum it would probably change the thinking in Brussels and if soft won, the deal may look a lot different.

Brussels is “staying out of it for now”, despite a whole raft of leaks that betray the position of Messrs Tusk, Juncker and Barnier. 

So, with a little over six months to go following the return of Parliament on September 4th, the odds must be shortening in favour of no deal, but I would be prepared to make a wager that there will be extension granted to the March 29 deadline if some kind of deal were even in the pipeline let alone close.

Share this article

Leave your comments

Post comment as a guest

terms and condition.
  • Jamie Walker

    There should be no debate about brexit, there should only be a collective will to deliver on what we voted for, we voted to leave the european union as well all its adjuncts like the single market and customs union, we voted to become independent from the EU so we, and we alone, could create our own laws and not be governed by a far off bureaucracy.

  • Laurie Anderson

    May is not delivering the BREXIT that was voted for and has to go.

  • Phillip Timmins

    I will never vote Tory again !!!!

  • Molly Holmes

    Well explained

  • Sophie Anne Smith

    Brexitards will just keep re-branding their shambolic project as we head towards the 29 March 2018. Funny how they spend time blaming every body else for their inadequacy, except themselves.

  • Tara Rampersad

    I think Mr Bean would do a better job than May. PM should be a Brexit voter, one of few who believes in our country.

  • Steven Doyle

    We should keep the 40 billions and have a no deal.

  • Mike Green

    I voted "leave", I didn't vote for a "deal" with the corrupt tyrants of the EU!

Share this article

Alan Hill

Political Expert

Alan is an award-winning market commentator, providing bespoke content delivery for all aspects of the FX Industry. He has been working in the financial services industry for over 30 years and has a wealth of experience across banks in Europe, North America and the Middle East. A former trader, Alan holds a bachelor of business administration in Politics and Economics from the Mark Hall School.

Cookies user prefences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Read more
Tools used to analyze the data to measure the effectiveness of a website and to understand how it works.
Google Analytics